Casting : Caroline Dhavernas (Alicia Milford) Noah Fleiss (unknown) Anna Holbrook (Mrs. Milford) Mark Jacoby (Mr. Milford) Peggy Gormley (Marsha Cannon) Christopher McCann (Drew Hamilton) Marilyn Caskey (Mrs. Cade) Paul DeBoy (Mr. Cade) Stuart Zagnit (Jim Roker) John Bolger (Mark Knapp) Gabriel Carpenter (John Lucero) Andrea Navedo (Detective Ann Cordova) Jake Smith (Peter Grimes) Tim Hewitt (Mr. Lucero) Richmond Hoxie (Elliot Marsh) Libby George (Sandra Hall) Jane Cecil (Martha Quinn) Fred Burrell (Bill Wilson) Margot Steinberg (Deborah Knapp) Melanie Nichols-King (Trina Felton) Christina Brucato (Monica Heath) Stephanie Gatschet (Matty Helder) John Gallagher, Jr. (Terrence Holt) Patrick Quinn (Dr. Grimes) Lauren C. Mayhew (Melissa Gelson) Liz Larsen (CSU Jessica Reed) Blythe Auffarth (Maura Tinley) Alicia Van Couvering (Jessica Rubin) Tom Demenkoff (McVitty) Elizabeth Flax (Vanessa) Vernice Miller (Anne)