Casting : Peter Jacobson (Randolph J. Dwarkin) John Rothman (Steven Strelzik) Jamie Goodwin (George Ashman) John E. Cariani (Julian Beck) Andrea Navedo (Detective Ann Cordova) Barbara Spiegel (Arraignment Judge Harriet Doremus) Emily Frankovich (Betsy) Delaine Yates (Susan Ashman) Larry Cahn (Dr. Marshall O'Grady) Ross Bickell (Judge Bryce Miller) David Wilson Barnes (Evan Hicks) James Hindman (Dean Riley) Michael Garfield (Officer Garvin) Will Chase (David) Adrian Rieder (Ryan Darby) Jonathan Sale (Marv) Alix Korey (Mrs. Rubin (Jury Foreperson)) Peter M. Karlin (Arnold Nathan) Ray Luetters (Owen) Ray Garvey (Rupert) John Farrell (Frank) Jordana Jacobs (Rachel Strelzik) Jerry Shulman (Bailiff #1) Reggie Alvin Green (Trial Bailiff) Stephanie Roth Haberle (Holly Strelzik (uncredited))