Casting : Gregory Hines (Carl Halpert) Oni Faida Lampley (Janet Thomas) Lisa Eichhorn (Dr. Gail Berardi) Leslie Hendrix (Medical Examiner Rodgers) Ato Essandoh (Jason Hendri) Chad C. Tucker (Stevie Thomas) Chris Tardio (Officer Adam Brennan) Claire Lautier (Officer Alice Cushman) Chris Messina (Don Cushman) Pippa Pearthree (Judge Esther Morrow) Doug Stender (Judge Joseph Flint) Andrea Navedo (Detective Ann Cordova) Cherene Snow (Assistant Principal Jill Balsom) Erica N. Tazel (Receptionist) Charles Tuthill (David Smith) Jeff Swanton (Rob) Robert Gerard Larkin (Jim) Barry Finkel (Clerk) Bernadette Drayton (Jury Foreman)