Casting : Ty Burrell (Herman Capshaw) Lisa Emery (Meg Lafferty) Hope Chernov (Maggie Barkman) Carolyn McCormick (Dr. Elizabeth Olivet) Sebastian Stan (Justin Capshaw aka Justin Lafferty) Trisha LaFache (Jenny Lafferty) Socorro Santiago (Anna Rodriguez) Dan Snook (Tom Lane) Lawrence David Kopp (Dr. Harlan Diamond) Howard W. Overshown (Kyle Rowen) Helmar Augustus Cooper (Arraignment Judge Lawrence McNeil) Lynn Cohen (Judge Elizabeth Mizener) John E. Cariani (Julian Beck) Andrea Navedo (Detective Ann Cordova) Gloria Biegler (Linda Sanders) Michael Quinlan (William Sanders) Connie Nelson (Marcia Healey) Tyrees Allen (Deputy Stanley) Tim Aherin (Borough Commander Clarke) Nelson Lee (Roy Leung) Marcella Lowery (Lois Barker) Michael Barry Green (Alan Geffin) Edwin Sean Patterson (Bob Webb) Laurie Gamache (Regina Loggerman) Laura Marie Duncan (Tracy Underwood) Ben Wang (Danny Chin) Joanna Lu (Grace Chin) Tom Bloom (Super) Joe Gonzalez (Sergeant Martinez) William H. Burns (Sergeant #2) Laura Michelle Smith (Amy Lane) Liz Larsen (CSU Technician Johnson) Welly Yang (Wesley Frost) Kirsten Sans (CSU Technician) Marisa Vural (Witness #1) Jo Yang (Witness #2) John Knox (Sheriff Bell) Dominic Marcus (Policeman #1) Derek Argobright (Policeman #2) Felice Yeh (Detective #1) Tim Miller (Court Clerk) Veronica Blackwell (Foreperson)