Casting : Henry Stram (as Eli Madison) Leslie Hendrix (as Elizabeth Rodgers) Dennis Boutsikaris (as Al Archer) Peter McRobbie (as Judge Walter Bradley) Susan Blommaert (as Judge Rebecca Steinman) Megan Byrne (as Myra Camp) Mark Kenneth Smaltz (as Arraignment Judge William Koehler) Lee Sellars (as Dr. John Faruzzi) John DiBenedetto (as Irv Groener) Ronnie Farer (as Diane Wharsey) Dean Nolen (as Professor Dan Enright) Colman Domingo (as Ronald Gumer) Kate Miller (as Madeline Myers) Reiner Schöne (as Marty) Frank Biancamano (as Jimmy) Sonia Manzano (as Barbara Benitez) Patrick Garner (as James Stryker) Kathleen McNenny (as Jennifer Shelby) Millie Tirelli (as Jill Kogen) Victor Anthony (as Manuel 'Manny' Esperanza) Christopher Danforth Wells (as Mark Clark) Charles Reed (as Evan Barry) Calli Sarkesh (as Jack Wilderman) Carolyn Craig (as Stephanie Vandenberg) Milena Davila (as Venice Munoz) Vaneik Echeverria (as Manager) Lulu Roche (as Andrea Brierly) Barbara Gulan (as Claudia Kowalski) Dillon Woolley (as Nick Kowalski) Joe Holt (as CSU Technician Richard Hardwick) Paolo Andino (as Jensen) Jack Neary (as Court Clerk) Claudia DiMartino (as Foreperson) Nick Taylor (as Foreperson #2)