Casting : Mark Zimmerman (Judge Nathan Murphy), Kevin Stapleton (Don Hamilton), Patrick Boll (Barry Bishop), Nicoye Banks (Officer Taylor), Teddy Cañez (Det. Davis), Zack Robidas (Officer Simone), Austin Jones (CSU Tech), Susanna Guzman (Nurse Esposito), Joseph Edward (Court Clerk), Charlie Sandlan (Detective Marlo), Matthew DeCapua (Uniform), Lena Armstrong (Jury Foreperson), Jaymie Dornan (John Carroll), Todd Gearhart (Attorney Rosenthal), Jose Zuniga (Detective Borough Investigator), Terri Garber (Mrs. Carroll), Paul Anthony Stewart (Gold), Jack Koenig (Carroll's Attorney), Jennifer Esposito (Attorney Bailey), Chevy Chase (Mitch Carroll), Leia Thompson (Tori), John E. Cariani (CSU Beck),Mark Kenneth Smaltz (Judge William Koehler), Ami Brabson (Judge Cale)