Casting : Fred Savage (Michael Gardner) Myndy Crist (Carrie Huitt) Tyra Ferrell (Bethany Taylor) Dana Eskelson (unknown) Lauren Ward (Erin Russ) Joel de la Fuente (CSU Technician Morales) Tamara Tunie (Medical Examiner Warner) Audrie J. Neenan (Judge Lois Preston) David Lipman (Arraignment Judge Arthur Cohen) Jenny Maguire (Kimberly Gardner) Annie Alvarez (Janet Todesco) Jennifer Riker (Renee Bassett) Ray Demattis (Artie Kabzinski) Christa Scott-Reed (Noreen) Paul Rolfes (Christian) Rick Johnson (Court Clerk) Scott Holroyd (Dean) Lisa Landry (Ilka) Adam J. Stern (Brendan Leighton) Willian H. Burns (Uniform Cop) Jason Schuchman (Paralegal)