Casting : Logan Marshall-Green (Mitch Wilkens) Ann Dowd (Sally Wilkens) Kieran Campion (Seth Wolfford, III) Matthew Bennett (unknown) Danny Hoch (unknown) Peter Hermann (Trevor Langan) Brette Taylor (Mrs. Dutton) Mark Jacoby (Phillip Dutton) Tamara Tunie (Medical Examiner Warner) Siobhan Fallon Hogan (Linda Leggatt) Daniel Letterle (Andrew Kenworthy) Sheila Tousey (Judge Danielle Larson) Ashley Burritt (Vienna Sterling) Mary McCann (Guidance Counselor) Ashton Holmes (Davis Harrington) Amber McDonald (Jenna Sterling) Eisa Davis (Vera Galeano) Ciaran Tyrrell (Keith) Peyton List (Chloe Dutton) Mary Beth O'Connor (Andrea Forbes) Denise Wilbanks (Doris Stark) Nicholas Hagelin (Bernie Thorkle) Brian Letscher (Paramedic) Welly Yang (CSU Technician Georgie) Heather Finn (Nancy) Susan Varon (Nurse Gruber) Miche Braden (Nurse Tolentino) Geoff Reinhard (Public Defender) Brian Coats (Jury Foreman) Dennis Vargas (Morgue Assistant)