Casting : Jeff Perry (as Andrew Soin) John Scurti (as Herman Mudgett) Seth Gilliam (as ADA Terence Wright) Aasif Mandvi (as Judge Samir Patel) Sandra Daley (as Althea Hill) Carey Lowell (as Judge Jamie Ross) Felix Solis (Miguel Guzman) Johanna Day (Jocelyn Webber) Ranjit Chowdhry (Anji Reddy) Keith Reddin (Marvin Figgs) Marc Aden Gray (Adam Burge) David Lipman (Judge Morris Torledsky) Ron Domingo (Albert Hsu) Aaron Lohr (Zack Stone) Mark Lotito (Sergeant Edward Kozak) Sharrieff Pugh (Sharaud Williams) Marisa Redanty (Leslie) Daniel Eric Gold (Nick) Ken Cheeseman (Patrick) Jonathan Daly (Sheldon) George Sheffey (Officer Ricky DeMateo) Scott Robertson (Bank Manager) Hudson Cooper (Bridge Officer)